« the Hatch/Wyden bill | Main | working with power »
July 08, 2003
new research on civic ed
I was in Boston today, for the International Society for Political Psychology's annual conference. I went to give a presentation on The Civic Mission of Schools. While there, I heard interesting papers on civic education and on the effects of public deliberation. I've summarized the latter papers on the DD-Net blog. Regarding civic education:
- Jon Miller of Northwestern
University Medical School presented a very important study that has followed 3,000
young Americans from 1987 to the present. Based on the data that his group has
collected, they are able to show what factors predict political engagement in
early adulthood. The courses taken in high school and students' performance in
these courses do not seem to matter at all. This finding is somewhat at odds with
the Civic Mission of Schools, which claims that school-based civic education
works, at least when done well.
There's a lot more to be said on this topic. For example, Miller's work doesn't distinguish between the kind of civic education that we would recommend and ordinary civic education. Furthermore, ordinary civic education does seem to increase students' knowledge, which can itself be considered a good. Still, it should give us pause to note that there was no observed connection between taking a government/civics class in high school and voting later on.
- Arthur "Skip" Lupia of Michigan is writing a very interesting book that applies insights from cognitive science to the question of civic education. There are obstacles to learning about civics that are hard-wired, he believes; and good teaching must address these obstacles. For example, when two equally respectable people say opposite things—which often happens in politics—we tend not to put either view into our long-term memories. I think it is undeniable that biological constraints are relevant. But I would have to be persuaded that the findings of cognitive science were very solid before I would want them to influence policy.
Posted by peterlevine at July 8, 2003 11:31 AM
Comments
Post a comment
This blog is under attack from comment spammers, who are causing a problem for the server. I believe I can block them by upgrading to a recent version of MoveableType. However, I do not have time to do that until late December. Therefore, I have temporarily disabled comments. Please feel free to email me feedback at plevine@umd.edu.